Pencil Me In Cosmetics – Natural Eyeliner Review

Im a total eyeliner girl. I love playing around with different brands, and lately Ive been on a quest to find the perfect pencil eyeliner. I already love powders they can be dampened and brushed on for vibrant color but finding a nice, not-too-pricey pencil liner that goes on smoothly and lasts all day is what I would like to find.

Enter Pencil Me In Cosmetics. Everything on their site intrigued me their models have gorgeous eyes, their shade selection is awesome, and their pencils uniquely feature:

  • All-natural ingredients, clinically tested
  • Anti-oxidants and vitamins to keep the eye area soft and smooth
  • A built-in sharpener in each pencil cap
  • Smooth, creamy application that doesnt pull on delicate eye skin

So I wrote to them, and they sent me a few shades to test for myself! I requested these three shades: Buff, Nutmeg, and Liberty Green (shown below in that order).

What I Like: They go on smoothly, and have a lovely creamy texture! The sharpener in the cap is so nice and convenient. The color lasts all day. And the shades are beautiful! The fact that they are all-natural is a huge plus for me, too.

What I dont like: My only problem with the pencils is that the shades I chose dont go on quite as dark as I would like, even with multiple layers. Also, its hard to create a fine, thin line with the creamy texture and size of the pencils.

Overall, Im very pleased with these pencils the cons I listed above would not stop me from ordering a few more pencils and collecting some darker shades that will show up more vibrantly, and the colors I chose are great if you want to layer coordinating shades.

My thoughts on the Buff Pencil: This is actually not an eyeliner shade meant to be put on by itself, but an accent pencil. According to the Pencil Me In Website, it has a creamy pale green hue color which can counteract redness giving the illusion of a bigger brighter wider eye. Im a worn out mom who deals with trying to cover up tired, red eyes on a daily basis, so I was thrilled to give it a try. And Im happy to be able to tell you that I was pleased with the result! It truly does help to cover up the red around your eyes, and prepares them for application of your regular eyeliner. This is a product I love!

Buy it! (And Deal Alert!)

Each pencil is $6.99, and Pencil Me In Cosmetics always has some great deals going on. Right now, they are offering:

Buy 2, Get 1 Free
Buy 4, Get 2 Free
and so on!

To take advantage of this great promotion, follow these directions:

Log onto and choose the pencil colors that you would like to purchase. Then proceed to the shopping cart page. On the shopping cart page, you will see in purple a link for this promotion. Click on it. The user name and password for this section is the same word: Healthy Choose your free pencils and proceed to check out!

You can also find the Pencil Me In Cosmetics line in professional beauty salons, spas, upscale cosmetic boutiques.

Email Newsletter: Sign up for their email newsletter for sale announcements, make-up tips, and more!

I would like to thank Pencil Me In Cosmetics for sending me the products reviewed above so that I could share my experiences with you! This review is my own opinion and was not edited or reviewed by anyone.